1/14/2025

Review of SM’s 30th Anniversary Concert: "A Five-Hour Showcase Focused Only on the Future, Ignoring the Past"

SM Entertainment’s SMTOWN LIVE 2025 concert, held to commemorate the company’s 30th anniversary, has garnered mixed reviews.

Over its five-hour runtime, legendary groups that built SM’s legacy were notably absent, and the heavy emphasis on future-oriented performances left the setlist feeling imbalanced.

■ Missing Legends

One of the most glaring omissions was the absence of full-group performances by Girls’ Generation and SHINee.

As cornerstone acts that elevated SM to its current status, their exclusion left a significant void in what should have been a celebration of SM’s history.

Taeyeon’s statement about her willingness to perform but lack of support from the agency has further raised questions about SM’s management of its legacy.

■ Unbalanced Setlist

The concert’s setlist was criticized for disrupting the flow of the show.

While TVXQ delivered a powerful opening with Rising Sun, the momentum was lost when trainees took the stage immediately afterward.

Super Junior’s decision to perform lesser-known tracks from their debut era, rather than their popular hits, also diminished audience engagement.

A Five-Hour Showcase Focused Only on the Future, Ignoring the Past

■ Overexposure of Rookies

A total of 25 trainees performed across three separate segments, and stages featuring the British boy group Dear Alice and virtual idol Naevis were also included.

While the intention to showcase a future-oriented concept is understandable, it ultimately interrupted the concert’s rhythm and heightened audience fatigue.

■ Lee Soo-man’s Absence

Former executive producer Lee Soo-man was invited to the event but did not attend.

His statement that he only learned of the invitation through media reports has fueled speculation about ongoing discord with the current management.

This has led to criticism that SM is failing to properly honor and manage its cultural heritage.

A Five-Hour Showcase Focused Only on the Future, Ignoring the Past

■ Highlights Amidst the Criticism

Some performances, such as BoA’s Hurricane Venus and aespa’s hit medley, successfully energized the audience.

However, the positive momentum from these stages was often disrupted by the inclusion of trainee and rookie group performances.

While the 30th-anniversary concert may have succeeded in presenting SM’s vision for the future, it fell short in celebrating the company’s rich history and traditions.

The absence of stages by legendary groups left fans deeply disappointed.

Industry observers view the concert as a symbolic representation of SM’s current management direction.

While the focus on future potential over past glories is understandable, critics caution against allowing this strategy to dilute the company’s identity and cultural value.

Latest

Subscribe to Updates
Receive exclusive content and promotions straight to your inbox.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Other Posts

キム・セロン事件の全貌と波紋:2025年に何が起きたのか
韓国芸能界が凍りついた2025年春。若手女優キム・セロンの死と、それに続く暴露の連鎖は、ただのゴシップでは済まされない深刻な問題を突きつけました。
4/2/25
Celeb
NewJeansとADOR:分裂の深層と法廷で揺れるK-POP業界
HYBE傘下という巨大な資本と、その中で育て上げられたNewJeans
3/24/25
Music
HYBE’s Eventful 2024: “From NewJeans Contract Termination to Bang Si-hyuk’s Controversies”
From Min Hee-jin-HYBE disputes to BTS Suga’s DUI incident… A tough year for K-pop’s largest corporation
12/30/24
Music
Fiery Priest 2 Ratings and OTT Rankings Surge Together: Praised for "Black Comedy Critique of Society"
Ranked #1 Among Domestic Miniseries and #2 on Disney+ Worldwide... Sharp Social Satire Combined with Humor Garners Attention
Actor Song Jae-Rim Passes Away... Allegations of Persistent Harassment by Japanese Sasaeng Fan
Months of Relentless Stalking Including Online Defamation and Distribution of Photos of Acquaintances... Police Confirm Discovery of a Suicide Note
11/14/24
Celeb
'T-ara Bullying Scandal' Reignited After 12 Years
Where Did the Lessons of the Past Go? The Storm Caused by MBK Entertainment's CEO's Comments on Variety Show
11/11/24
Celeb
HYBE COO Kim Tae-ho: "All Allegations Are Unfounded"... Addresses Concerns at Parliamentary Audit
Denies Allegations of Album Stockpiling and Infringement of Minors' Rights... "Awaiting Judicial Decision on Plagiarism Dispute"
10/24/24
Music
LE SSERAFIM Silences Skill Controversy at Fall University Festivals… “Clearly Improved Live Performance”
First University Festival Since Coachella… Members Receive Praise for Enhanced Vocal Skills and Stage Presence
10/2/24
Music